20.04.2009

Sham Contracts

Sham Contracts

twitter icon

In Protectacoat Firthglow Ltd v Szilagyi Mr Szilagyi claimed unfair dismissal by Protectacoat. Protectacoat argued that Mr S. was a partner and referred to a written partnership agreement. Mr S. however argued that as far as practical arrangements were concerned (for example his company vehicle and tools and the company control over his work) he was in fact an employee. The Employment Tribunal held that the "partnership agreement" was a sham and that Mr S. was an employee. The Court of Appeal clarified the principle that the question is always what the true legal relationship between the parties is. Normally the contractual document shows this, but it is up to the court to decide whether this reflects the true relationship. Additionally the written document does not have to been intended to deceive in order for it to be held to be a sham. The important lesson from this is that employers must have clear and lawful legal relationships with their employees. A written document that does not reflect the true relationship is no protection where rights have been infringed.

Sue is Director and Principal Consultant of Employment & Safety Advice Ltd. Sue heads up a small team of consultants who offer HR support for companies of all sizes. Existing clients include staging…

Follow us for more articles and posts direct from professionals on      

DATA and AI for Leaders

Data and AI for Leaders Build confidence in your understanding of data and artificial intelligence (AI) and use new…
Liverpool, SEO expert, SEO Experts

Top SEO Experts in Liverpool - Nadeem Ansari

In the rapidly shifting landscape of digital marketing, few figures command the same blend of academic rigour,…
Surrey, IT Support, Remote IT Support

Best IT Support Company Surrey

Businesses rely heavily on technology to operate efficiently, yet even minor technical disruptions can cause costly…

More Articles

Executive Travel, Airport Transfer Service

Private Airport Transfers Liverpool

Liverpool's Premier Chauffeur Service - Prestige Platinum Chauffeurs - Call 0151 808 4706Experience first-class travel…
Seo, Local SEO, Liverpool, Quantum SEO

SEO Experts in Liverpool

  Top SEO Experts in Liverpool Nadeem Ansari Nadeem Ansari FCIM FIDM is a highly distinguished marketing veteran and…
Skip hire, Eco Skips, SkipPermit, Best Skips

Best Skip Hire Company in Liverpool

Kirkby Skips Ltd are proud to reach a new milestone in sustainable waste management. We are the first skip company in…

Would you like to promote an article ?

Post articles and opinions on Liverpool Professionals to attract new clients and referrals. Feature in newsletters.
Join for free today and upload your articles for new contacts to read and enquire further.